Run Lola Run: Free Will vs. Determinism Argument #2

Example #2:

 Each time Lola is running, she encounters different bystanders or strangers each time. What follows is a series of snapshots, which are glimpses into the future of each of the bystander’s lives of what happens when they encounter Lola running. For example, Lola bumps into a blonde elderly lady during her run, and we as viewers get a scoop on what happens to her in the future:
In Run 1. She is stealing a child after her miscarriage
In Run 2. Winning the lottery and living lavishly
           In Run 3. Praying in the church of God and being baptised as a religious being
I thought that the film’s use of this was quite unique. I interpreted that it was communicating with us how one person or a “minor occurrence” can have a huge impact on our fate.On each run, we see that the lady’s outcomes were different. In this case, it was Lola, whose presence seemed to have a drastic effect on the people’s lives. This kind of relates to the cause and effect chain in which determinism is similar towards. According to the Webster Dictionary, fate is defined as "the development of events beyond a person's control, regarded as determined by a supernatural power." By Lola bumping into the elderly woman each time on he run, we can assume that this particular action had lead to and caused those specific outcomes to occur. Therefore, her destiny was tied to a past event (which in this case, was Lola's ecounter).
If we really did have free will, then we can as humans would be in control of our own drives and outcomes. We would then assume that the lady would have chosen One of these circumstances each time only (which would probably have resulted in winning the jackpot lottery), however, that wasn’t the case. I think determinism and or destiny is the most plausible reason behind this scene, rather than free will. I also discovered that this phenomenon is known as the butterfly effect, which is when a small action causes a large event to take place.


 
The First Run and Encounter


The Second Run and Encounter



The Third Run and Encounter




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Run Lola Run: Free Will vs. Determinism Argument #3

Another example and scene in the film that demonstrates this is on Lola’s second run where she obtains a gun from the cop and uses it to threaten father (at gunpoint) to give her $100,000 in cash. Lola obviously didn’t have to take the gun from the cop if she didn’t want to, but she did anyway base on her own desire to do so. This demonstrates the idea of free will again. However, from a determinist lens perspective, perhaps her action in doing so was determined. Based on how she had to come up with the $100000 to save Manni, her taking the gun to use age leverage was sparked by a previous action/experience that drove her to do so. Thus, since this happened on her second run/attempt, she had learned lessons previously from past run, which allowed her to experience empiricism. In following this scene and idea, I wanted to connect and point out something out that I also recognized in the film. Tykwer uses a bit of animation in this film, which can be seen the clip below. As viewers
Read more

Slumdog Millionaire (Determinism)

Image
In the film Slumdog Millionaire, t he movie opens with a question and a set of answers in the style of ‘Who Wants to be a Millionaire’. “Jamal Malik is one question away from winning 20 Million Rupees. How did he do it? (A) He cheated (B) He's lucky (C) He's a genius (D) It is written I thought that this was a clever approach in which the filmmakers did, since this is the exact same question and answer format that is seen on the game show “Who Wants to Be a Millionaire,” ( “WWTBM”) which plays a large role in the movie. Yet after seeing this phrase, it was brought to my attention that the themes of both Free Will vs Destiny (or determinism) were bound to be prominent over the course of the film. As free will and determinism have been debated for over centuries, Slumdog Millionaire demonstrates how we do not have free will, but rather, live by the idea of destiny and fate, as seen through Jamal’s character. In answering the question that is presented to
Read more